Conservatives today are reasoning from entirely different moral premises. Is unity possible?
Two Different Scandals, Two Very Different Responses
When news broke this week that Christie’s aides and political appointees caused traffic problems in Fort Lee, New Jersey as part of a political retribution scheme, the TV talk shows went into a frenzy. The events, dubbed “Bridgegate,” quickly turned into a full-blown scandal.
The week’s events reminded of another recent scandal, the Obama administration’s response to the attacks in Benghazi, Libya. Though there are several similarities between the two — for example, both cases involved the higher-ups blaming their subordinates and denying all knowledge of wrongdoing — the leadership displayed after the fact was markedly different.
First, Gov. Christie. In a press conference that lasted over 90 minutes, Christie directly and straightforwardly apologized for the misconduct of his staff, answered seemingly dozens of questions, and still managed to emphatically deny his involvement. Even the Washington Post claimed Christie did “everything humanly possible” to address the crisis.
That’s an important point to note. Immediately after the Benghazi attacks, the Obama administration (including Secretary of State Hillary Clinton) continued to issue statements apologizing for the United States’ supposed intolerance toward other religions.
However, after enduring much criticism from the media, foreign policy analysts, and even foreign leaders, the administration finally withdrew that talking point, acknowledging that the Benghazi attack had in fact been a coordinated terrorist attack. Yet Clinton still blamed faulty “intelligence,” despite the fact that a simple discussion with those at the scene revealed a completely different story.
When evidence then surfaced that the State Department had continually denied adequate security to the Benghazi embassy despite dangerous conditions, a narrative of political motives emerged.
But where Christie accepted full responsibility for his staff’s indiscretion, Clinton exploded at a congressional committee hearing, yelling “What difference at this point does it make?”
Imagine if Gov. Christie had offered the same comment. There is no doubt that the media would have crucified him. Yet, for some reason, everyone seems to think Christie’s possible involvement in local traffic jams is more serious than Clinton’s irreverence for attacks that resulted in four dead Americans.
Every headline asks the same question – is Gov. Christie out of the running for 2016? But, mysteriously, the same is not asked of Hillary Clinton. Barbara Walters of ABC News declared her the “most fascinating person of 2013,” and CNN and NBC planned documentaries extolling Clinton’s “intelligence, fortitude, and a deep commitment to bettering the lives of women and children worldwide.“
Doesn’t it seem a bit one-sided?
Get the Collegiate Experience You Hunger For
Your time at college is too important to get a shallow education in which viewpoints are shut out and rigorous discussion is shut down.
Explore intellectual conservatism
Join a vibrant community of students and scholars
Defend your principles
Join the ISI community. Membership is free.
What We Celebrate on the Fourth of July: Calvin Coolidge on the Declaration of Independence
President Calvin Coolidge reflects on the significance and meaning of the Fourth of July.